Showing posts with label change in the church. Show all posts
Showing posts with label change in the church. Show all posts

Friday, September 9, 2016

7 Ways an Interim Pastor can help a Church in Transition

When a church finds itself without a pastor—whether because of resignation, firing, or death—it is a crucial time. It could be a time when a church comes apart, or it could be that the congregation comes together. If the church is independent, or affiliated with a denomination in which each congregation is responsible to find a new pastor, suddenly being without a leader is very scary for the leadership board of the church, the staff, and the members. Too many times when churches call a new pastor, particularly after long tenured pastor, the next pastor becomes what could be called an unintentional interim pastor and only stays an often difficult year or two. This is because the church didn’t take the time to heal any wounds and prepare for a new direction under a new leader. A good interim pastor can do a lot to help a congregation navigate this unsettled, often stormy time. Here are seven ways an interim pastor can help.

1. The Interim Pastor becomes a consistent face and voice in the pulpit.
People want to know what to expect when they come to worship on Sunday morning. If the pulpit is filled week to week by a variety of speakers that may, or may not be available in its area, the church may find the quality of the preaching to be unsteady. The interim pastor can keep up the interest of worship attenders and speak with areas that may help the church deal with the loss of the former pastor. There may well be hurt, conflict, and confusion in the church, and the interim pastor will be able to get the feel for where the church needs help and “scratch where they itch.” Also he can preach messages and message series to help keep the church from turning in on itself and becoming inward focused.

2. A good interim pastor can help the church deal with the changes that are inevitable with the coming of a new pastor.
Change is often the biggest issue when a church is without a pastor. Change or lack of change may have been the issue that led to the former pastor’s departure. An interim pastor can help the congregation deal with its fear of change and prepare them for the new vision the new pastor will bring. He can talk about Jesus’ purpose for the church: to make more disciples, and help them see that change is good if the object of the change is to make more disciples of Christ. The interim pastor can begin turning a fear of change into an expectation for a new and greater day.

3. An interim can help members deal with the loss of the last pastor.
The consistent presence of an interim pastor can help the people know someone is at the helm of the church. On a more personal level, an interim pastor can help people work through their personal issues, and/or grief as they miss the former pastor. In addition, it’s reassuring for the people to know that someone is on hand if they need help in a family tragedy or a personal trauma. Furthermore, if there are tensions that have been caused by the circumstances that brought about the departure of the former pastor, the interim pastor can work on peacemaking and reconciliation within the church.

4.The interim pastor can be a great resource for the Search Team and Board.
Hopefully, it has been a while since the congregation has had to look for a new pastor. If the church is independent has congregational polity, the Search Team may well need help getting started. They will need someone in the denomination to contact to get their position posted and find out which pastors are looking for a position. Also he can help them find other pastoral placement organizations that could be helpful. When the team gets together, the interim pastor can help the Search Team focus on what kind of person the church needs to be the next pastor to lead the church into a new life cycle. He can help them answer questions like:  What kind of a surveys should we do to find out the thinking of the congregation? Do we need a consultation team to help us evaluate where we are as a church, and if so, how do we find a good consultant firm?

5. He can give leadership to the staff and resource them in a time of uncertainty.
Having an interim pastor sitting in the lead pastor’s chair can enable the staff to continue to work together on accomplishing the Great Commission and the Great Commandments in the church and community.

Many churches require the rest of the staff to offer their resignations when the lead pastor leaves so that the new pastor can build his own team. Often the new pastor will retain at least part of the staff, but for this, and a multitude of other reasons, time between pastors is very unsettling for the staff. An interim pastor can be a sounding board when the staff gets nervous. He will be able to dampen the effects of the natural upheaval that comes when leadership changes, and he may be able to help them start their searches for new positions.

6. An interim can analyze the church’s structure and help them adopt a new structure if needed.
In churches with congregational polity, sometimes the structure of the church is problematic. Perhaps the bylaws need to be updated, or even totally rewritten so that new leadership can make sense of them. It would be tragic if a good pastoral candidate didn’t consider the church because he/she was put off by antiquated bylaws that he had no idea how to use.

In churches that have a prescribed structure the interim could make sure the membership and attendance statistics are up to date and that the structure the church is using is the appropriate one for the size it is now.

7. An interim can get the church ready for the coming of a new pastor.
If the church has had the same pastor for many years, and especially if the church has grown during that time, some of the members will have a hard time imagining another pastor in the pulpit. The presence of an interim pastor helps the church get used to another person filling the role. Members can become able to picture someone, with a different style, and a different approach, leading their church. The interim pastor can talk about great days ahead for the church and help them look forward to a new vision and a new life-cycle with excitement instead of dread.

Churches need to resist the temptation to try to save the money they would’ve paid a pastor during the time they don’t have one. The months between pastors become very important as the church turns the page and closes the chapter of its history that was written by the old leader and prepares itself to begin writing a new chapter under new leadership. A good interim pastor can help the congregation do that and is well worth a salary.

Effective interim pastors should be people called to that ministry and not people marking time until retirement, or retirees “just keeping their hand in”, or people who have repeatedly failed as pastors. Interim pastors may work part time, or full time depending on the needs and size of the church. It should be very, very rare for an interim pastor to become the next pastor of the church. If he wants to be the permanent pastor, he should apply for that job, and not accept the interim position. The interim needs to be a free agent, able to do what is best to prepare the church for its next chapter.


The most important thing when a church loses a pastor for whatever reason is to prepare for the future God has in mind. Whenever a church finds itself in that position it should seriously consider finding an interim to help them.

Monday, May 12, 2014

Potholes for the Turn-Around Church and Pastor


The dream of being a turn-around pastor comes when a pastor looks at a church that’s not producing fruit and realizes that God wants him to do something about it. Usually, he sees something in that congregation that others can’t or won’t see. It’s a glorious challenge that some pastors accept. Sometimes, he has to work hard to get the congregation to simply recognize that changes need to be made. Then he must convince the people that things can be different and that they can, with God’s help, regain positive momentum. Once the church agrees to be open to the pastor’s leadership, the temptation is for the pastor to think he’s home free because everyone is behind him and the church is on its way to new relevance, strength and growth. He thinks that since the church has decided to make the U-turn, things should be easy now. However, as difficult as it is to get a declining or plateaued congregation to agree it needs to make changes, the would-be turn-around pastor should be aware that more opposition is likely. There are potholes in the road after the church turns around.

Check out the book of Nehemiah. The project God assigned was to rebuild the wall of Jerusalem. This was the start of the turn-around for the city after its destruction by the Babylonians. Nehemiah received a vision from God. He got the okay from the king. He had every reason to believe that he would be successful, but he still had plenty of continuing opposition to overcome.

Turnaround pastors can learn from Nehemiah that even with assurance of success, you can expect opposition when you strive to fulfill God’s dream. It’s easier to deal with a pothole if you know to expect them. Here are some of the things you can expect to hear:
-        “This is not the right time.” These folks will say they agree that the church needs to change, but this is just a bad time to make those changes. They will point to any one of a number of things as evidence—from a bad economy to the wrong time of year. Delay is their goal.
-         “It will take too much time.” Those in opposition will say they don’t really believe it can be done because they believe either the pastor or the people will lose interest or become exhausted before the job is done.
-        “Your dream is too expensive.” This point of view may well have contributed to the decline or plateau the church has experienced. These people have yet to realize that turning the church around is the most important thing the church spends money on.
-        “Your results will not be done well.” This may imply that the speaker doesn’t believe the pastor is smart enough or competent enough to lead the church to turn around. Or it could be that the speaker has no confidence in the ability of their people doing things effectively.
-        Some who oppose may be crass enough to use ridicule to try to demoralize the pastor or the people, so that they will just give up.
-        Elements of the opposition may try to find ways to halt renewal efforts by finding obscure bylaws clauses or parliamentary procedures.

The turn-around pastor must then anticipate opposition and find ways to counteract the influence of the opposition. Either he can steer around the pothole or brace himself and his supporters for them.
-        First of all make sure you stay close to the Lord. God will give you the assurance and encouragement you need.
-        Make sure you spend time with people who encourage you.
-        Listen to encouraging words and music. Fill your mind with good stuff.
-        Don’t just be a consumer of encouragement, but also give encouragement to your supporters whenever and however you can.
-        Prepare well. Make sure you know as much about what you’re doing as you can. Be ready for questions. Have answers.
-        Work hard. Let your effort show the way.
-        Do all you can do and trust God! Do your best. Remember that is all you have to do and all that God expects of you.

It seems that there will always be negative people. Some of them think that their purpose is to cause potholes in your path. They have no dreams and resent the fact that you actually think you can achieve yours. Do your best not to let them bother you, because when it comes down to it, what do negative people win?  All they win is a jeering laugh at the expense of the person who is trying to make the dream come true. On the other hand, what does the dream achiever win?  Usually he achieves the objective, and win or lose, he always receives God’s approval.

Remember that turning a church around is difficult. Admit that. Know that. Deal with that. Let the congregation know that turning the church around will be tough, but keep reminding yourself and them that, “It is not the things we fail at that shame us, it’s the things we should have done, and could have done, but never even tried.” In football they tell players to “leave it all on the field”, which is to say, don’t hold anything back. Turning a church around is your SuperBowl. It is the ultimate test for the pastor and for the people. If God is calling you to be a turn-around pastor, don’t let potholes scare you away. It’s worth the risk. It’s worth the effort. Go for it! 

Click here Check out my post, "The Turn-around Challenge: Will You Take the First Steps to Turn Around Your Church", from February 18, 2014




Monday, April 14, 2014

Fickle Holy Week Crowd – Fickle Congregations

The crowd in Jerusalem was a fickle bunch. On Palm Sunday they welcomed Jesus as a new king coming to lead the Jews to throw off the oppression of Rome and establish Israel as God’s great kingdom on earth. By Friday morning they were yelling for Pilate to crucify Him. How could they change so fast? I know the easiest answer is that the Sunday crowd and the Friday crowd were not the same. Maybe that’s true, but if it is, what happened to the Sunday crowd? Why didn’t they show up on Friday when the heat was on Jesus?

Actually, this kind of sea change is often seen in congregations. Pastors are welcomed with great fanfare. They are invited to lead the congregation. The church believes that he can get the congregation off a plateau or bring it back from near death. The people can’t wait to see their church return and perhaps surpass its glorious past. They are sure that soon things will right themselves and it will be just like the good old days. This pastor is a leader and they know if they just have a leader their congregation will succeed.

When Jesus entered Jerusalem the crowd were sure He was the king they wanted. Even though they were greatly outnumbered by the Romans, a King Jesus could heal their wounded and restore their dead to life. If their supply lines got thin, Jesus could multiply rations like He did with the loaves and fishes in Galilee.

It didn’t turn out that way. Instead of rousing the crowd against the Romans, He went to the temple and deliberately irritated the temple authorities. He even went so far as to disrupt their money-changing operation. When He should have been getting people mad at the Romans, He criticized the Jewish authorities that He needed to legitimize His kingship. Jesus was leading a revolution, but not the revolution they wanted. So … “Crucify Him!” “Crucify Him!”

The new pastor turns out not to be what they thought. He has some strange ideas about how things ought to be done. He makes big changes in the music. He brings in guitars and drums, and not just on youth Sunday, but every Sunday. The choir is down to singing only once a month and the only time the organ is heard any more is at a funeral. He’s got somebody leading some kind of recovery group and a few of those people have been showing up in church. Somehow he got the board to let him remodel the children’s area with all kinds of wild color schemes and decorations. It looks more like a fun area than a classroom. And there are so many kids running around making noises and messes … It’s not at all like it used to be. Sure, the attendance is coming up, but those people aren’t like us. They don’t know how to dress for church. They have tattoos and some of them smell like tobacco. He doesn’t seem to care about the way things have always been done and doesn’t think he needs the approval of the long-time lay leaders. The church may be growing, but it’s not growing the way they want. The pastor is a leader, but he’s not leading the way they wanted. Someone get up a petition; let’s get rid of him. In effect, “Crucify him!” “Crucify Him!”

The Holy Week crowd got rid of Jesus and preserved the way things were, but in a relatively few years the temple system was destroyed. The local lay leaders usually get their way too, and while they may preserve the traditions of their congregation, the church dies in a few years. Sometimes, the pastor survives and leads another congregation to growth. Too often, he’s so damaged that he decides to walk away from pastoral leadership.


Jesus was just doing what God sent Him to do, and the crowd reversed itself. In the same way, the pastor was doing the Lord’s assignment too, and the congregation turned on him. It’s a small consolation for the pastor to realize that he faced the same thing Jesus did. The congregation, like the Holy Week crowd, couldn’t trade their pipe dream of the future for God’s vision. They couldn’t submit to God.

Saturday, March 15, 2014

When Should Your Church Begin a Second Worship Service?

Many times it happens like this scenario:
The capacity of your church’s sanctuary (auditorium, worship room, multi-ministry room, whatever you call it in your congregation) is around 220 and your church attendance is picking up. Your average attendance passed 150 a month or so ago and you continue to see new faces. You look at the records for the last few decades and you find that three times the church has grown to between 170 and 180 and then retreated. The congregation went down to about 100 before it started this last resurgence under the new young pastor who is a very good speaker and has lots of new ideas. The changes he has proposed seem to be paying off and many Sundays the sanctuary feels full. Some of the folks are very excited about it, and most of the rest feel good about it. There are, however, some who are getting nervous that the church is not the same.

You’re thinking that it’s good that it’s not the same, because people are finding the Lord and want to join the congregation, but you also see a problem. Last week, when the children sang in worship, there weren’t enough seats, and the ushers had to scramble to add chairs down the center aisle and in the lobby. The pastor was almost ecstatic and you were just about as happy. On the other hand, Mr. and Mr. Brewster who have been in this church for over 50 years arrived a little late and a new family was seated in the Brewsters’ usual place. For years, you had heard how much the Brewsters love the congregation and how they want to see it be strong and growing, but they looked very unhappy when they had to sit in the lobby.

Since the new pastor has been at your church there has been talk about adding on. You talked to a friend of yours who owns a company that builds supermarkets and other large buildings. He gave you what he said was a very ballpark estimate of the costs to build a new room for worship and you know that those costs were well out of reach. You even discussed it with the pastor, and he estimated that the attendance would have to just about double before a major building project could be considered.

If the church continues to grow, the size of the sanctuary will very soon be a problem. The growth has not been meteoric—just 7 or 8 percent per year—a pace that you hope continues. If it does, the church will begin to feel crowded and there will be no room for continued growth. At board meeting the pastor passed out an article that said if a worship facility is more than 75-80% full, growth is severely retarded. Your church is getting close to that mark, and your research showed that, in the past, the congregation had stopped growing every time it reached that level.

A few times the pastor has mentioned starting a second service. Until now, you have not been excited about that. In fact, you are still not particularly excited about it, but you see it is probably the best solution to the problem that is looming just ahead for this church.

Now what? What’s the best way for a church to move to two worship services? How do you get the congregation to accept the idea?

1. Clearly make the case to the lay leaders using the statistics and vision.

2. Ask lay leaders who accept the idea to help get the rest of the church on board.
The major objections will likely be, “We have always been a family and we won’t know everybody any more.” The truth is that if the church is larger than 50, they don’t all know each other anyway. Having one service preserves the illusion that they do and changing to two services kills that illusion. Adding a service will not make them know less people, and it may broaden their friendship circle. The best way to counter this objection is for the members to be more uncomfortable that people the church could reach are being left out. Perhaps ask, “Who do we want to tell to stay away?” Also, it is important to give the members time to process the idea of two services.

3. Decide if you will have two duplicate services or if they will be different.
Some churches choose to have contemporary and traditional services. This can help alleviate the music style controversy many churches face, but it creates a lot more work for the music people, and may create two churches in one.

4. Get the worship team on board or recruit a second team for the new service.
It is crucial to have the cooperation of the worship team.

5. Decide the time for the new service.
Some churches decide to have the added service simultaneous with Sunday school. Others choose to have it the hour before Sunday school. Having two services and two simultaneous Sunday schools works for some churches, even though it takes a lot of volunteers. Other churches choose to discontinue Sunday school, encourage small groups during the week and provide children’s church for both services. One very important factor in this decision is the amount of parking. People can’t sit in the church if they can’t find a place to park. If the parking lot has to be emptied between services, that will be a major factor in determining the schedule.

6. Recruit ushers and greeters, and all the other volunteers you will need for Sunday school or children’s church.
The availability of volunteers may help determine the new service scenario the church chooses.

7. Ask a number of people to commit to the new service for a year or 18 months.
The number depends on the need at your church. In the story above, 50 or 75 might be sensible. You need enough people committed to the new service to effectively relieve the crowding at the existing service and to be enough that they don’t feel like they’re the only ones there.


Bathe the whole idea in prayer. This is a very major step for congregations, especially those long-established ones. If the church can take this step, it may well find itself on the road to new levels of growth, which means many people in their community will find the love, hope and salvation of Jesus.